South Africa’s metals and engineering sector has endured more than 15 years of deterioration. Industry economic assessments put the compound annual decline in production at approximately 2%, with capacity utilisation falling below 50% in parts of the industry. More than 220,000 jobs have been lost over this period. Behind those figures are factories struggling to survive and households stripped of an income.
Two failures have compounded the damage. South Africa invests too little in infrastructure, and too much of the industrial demand generated by the infrastructure built is significantly imported. Industry analysis put imports at approximately 45% of the primary steel market in 2026. Meanwhile, pension fund investment in infrastructure has too often been approached narrowly as a financial transaction, missing opportunities to connect investment with local manufacturing and reindustrialisation.
The Engineering Industries Pension Fund and Metal Industries Provident Fund sought to address that disconnect. These funds, together representing one of the country’s largest pools of private retirement capital, established a special purpose vehicle to support infrastructure development while deliberately advancing domestic industrial capacity. The proposition was to connect infrastructure investment with the productive economy that sustains the funds’ contributing members.
Legal, commercial, technical and financial specialists were engaged to develop the structure. Its novelty in South Africa was recognised during its development; advisers indicated that other funds were considering similar approaches. Novelty requires careful examination. It should also require a regulator to understand the proposition before passing judgment. Protecting members’ retirement savings remains fundamental, and the structure must stand up to scrutiny on that basis.
The FSCA subsequently raised concerns following what the funds were told was an anonymous complaint about the processes followed in establishing the vehicle. Its intervention has, in practical terms, largely stalled the initiative. Yet repeated formal requests for the complaint, including a redacted version, have not produced it.
Protecting a complainant’s identity need not mean withholding the substance of allegations. The funds have asked for disclosure that would allow the funds to understand and answer the case being advanced. A regulator demanding transparency should explain its own failure to provide that clarity. Without it, how are the funds to test whether this process rests on substantiated concerns? That is the double standard at the heart of this dispute: accountability demanded from trustees, with too little offered in return.
The funds nevertheless participated in several meetings that the FSCA described as an information gathering exercise. The funds supplied substantial information and explained aspects of the structure that had been misunderstood. These engagements took place on a without prejudice basis, and the funds approached the engagements in good faith as an opportunity to resolve the regulator’s concerns.
My experience of those engagements raises a more troubling question: was the FSCA gathering information with an open mind, or seeking confirmation of a conclusion already reached? The approach left me with the clear impression that the matter had been prejudged on an incorrect understanding of material facts. An information gathering exercise loses credibility when explanations appear to encounter a settled position.
In those discussions, FSCA representatives also acknowledged, as we understood their responses, that certain interpretations of critical legal aspects required correction following the funds’ explanations. That should have prompted reconsideration. Instead, we encountered an approach we regarded as hostile. Regulatory authority does not excuse an inadequate grasp of the structure under examination.
Until then, these exchanges had remained between the regulator and the funds. We respected that process and did not conduct it through the media. The latest meeting took place on 10 November 2026. On 11 November, media queries began reaching individual fund representatives, myself included, about their involvement in the initiative.
The timing is troubling. The specificity is more so. Some questions closely mirrored those raised by FSCA representatives at the meeting, extending to questions about the same particular clauses. This was an overlap in the detail of the questioning, immediately after a confidential engagement.
In my view, that coincidence is too striking to ignore. It raises a serious suspicion that information from the engagement reached the media. I cannot establish who supplied it, and the similarity alone does not prove an FSCA disclosure. It does, however, demand an explanation and examination of how the information was handled. The reputations of identifiable individuals are now exposed while the underlying regulatory concerns remain unresolved.
The FSCA must answer a direct question: is it confining itself to impartial regulation, or has information obtained through that role been used by any of its officials to influence media coverage? If any official supplied confidential material for that purpose, it would be an abuse of the trust on which regulatory engagement depends. The Commissioner must establish whether that happened. Regulatory power must never become an instrument for media games.
Before determining my next steps, I will seek an urgent audience with the FSCA Commissioner. This will be to require clarity on the complaint and the substantive objections to the structure, an examination of confidentiality concerns, and a fair process for resolving the matter. Officials’ conduct must be open to scrutiny alongside that of trustees.
The industrial consequences cannot be dismissed. An initiative intended to connect retirement capital with infrastructure and local production has largely stalled amid unresolved disputes about its structure and establishment. Workers continue to lose livelihoods while the process drags on. The FSCA must resolve legitimate concerns on their merits and account for its own conduct. South Africa’s industrial recovery cannot be held hostage to an opaque regulatory process.



